Chinese Overproduction Creates Problems for Low- and Middle-Income Countries
Chinese overproduction of goods creates problems not only for the United States and Europe, but also for low- and middle-income countries, according to a report from the Peterson Institute for International Economics (PIIE). China continues to export record volumes of light industrial products. For poor economies, this prevents the development of their own production: increasing exports and gradually transitioning to the manufacture of more complex products. According to analysts' estimates, due to competition with China, other countries are losing hundreds of billions of dollars in export revenue.
In recent years, discussions about China's growing trade surplus have focused mainly on the problems this creates for the United States and Europe. These include job losses in manufacturing and intensifying competition in the automotive and strategic industries.
However, the consequences of overproduction in China for low- and middle-income countries have often been underestimated, according to PIIE experts.
This refers to countries with a gross national income per capita of less than $14,375 per year (World Bank classification) — a group that includes both poor economies and relatively large emerging markets ranging from Niger to India.
Many of these countries compete directly with China in sectors where production requires relatively low technological capabilities. According to PIIE's assessment, of approximately $2.2 trillion in China's trade surplus, a significant portion — between $0.7 trillion and $1.4 trillion — falls precisely into such sectors. These include the production of clothing, footwear, textiles, furniture, and other mass-market goods.
Analysts identify several channels of Chinese pressure. First and foremost is competition in the global export market: developing countries could sell more light industrial products to the world, but China occupies a significant portion of this niche.
There is also competition in the domestic markets of developing countries themselves: Chinese goods displace local producers not only in the United States or the European Union, but also in countries in Asia, Africa, and South America.
The authors emphasize that export data may even underestimate the scale of the problem. If we look not only at finished goods crossing borders, but also at the value added created within China, its role turns out to be even more significant. China may export less finished clothing or footwear, but increasingly more stages of their production occur within the country.
Experts consider China's position unusual. When present-day developed countries were at a comparable stage of development to China, they gradually ceded ground to poorer producers. The United States in the 1960s opened its market to the "Asian Tigers," and later to China itself. According to the authors, China imports significantly less from low- and middle-income countries than its "predecessors" did.
Weak domestic demand in China exacerbates the problems. Due to excess capacity and intense competition, Chinese companies are increasingly pushing their products into foreign markets, often engaging in dumping. As a result, developing countries find it difficult not only to export their own goods, but also to protect domestic producers in their home markets.
Poor countries cannot launch industrial growth due to Chinese overproduction and gradually transition to more complex products. Experts call this effect the "China Squeeze" — a narrowing of space for industrialization.
According to the authors' assessment, in categories such as clothing, textiles, footwear, and leather goods alone, China's "excess" exports in 2022 could have amounted to approximately $110 billion. If other sectors are taken into account, the figure reaches $365 billion. Analysts estimate this as the lost export revenue of developing countries.
By Christina Borovikova